The buildup with Nihilus resulted in an extremely mediocre encounter where he poses no threat since you're his only weakness. I would prefer 2 if the ending didn't disappoint me and feel like Obsidian noticed they had a deadline to meet and just ended the game. Overall the soundtrack in 1 stood out to me more even if the theme for the rebuilt jedi enclave is really great.
The planets in 1 felt more alive and while that wouldn't go well with the themes in 2 I couldn't help but think that hampered some of my enjoyment. Because even if I think 2 has a more interesting plot and characters there was just something about it that never pulled me in.
